Why do we keep trash cards

Forum rules
Please DO NOT POST BUGS on this forum. Please report (and vote) bugs on : https://boardgamearena.com/bugs
User avatar
bergerOUS
Posts: 40
Joined: 04 November 2023, 13:57

Re: Why do we keep trash cards

Post by bergerOUS »

I don't think that there are real trash cards in the game, some birds are not very usefull to play but you can tuck them or give them away to get extra food... so it depends on you to use the cards you got as well as you can.
FrankJones
Posts: 2928
Joined: 30 June 2024, 00:24

Re: Why do we keep trash cards

Post by FrankJones »

bergerOUS wrote: ↑01 January 2026, 14:22 I don't think that there are real trash cards in the game, some birds are not very usefull to play but you can tuck them or give them away to get extra food... so it depends on you to use the cards you got as well as you can.
A bird that serves only to discard for food is a bad card. At some point, we need to play birds onto our tableau. It's frustrating to draw birds that are generally useless to play.
User avatar
Madlaine
Posts: 66
Joined: 20 January 2022, 12:46

Re: Why do we keep trash cards

Post by Madlaine »

Great Crested Flycatcher is uterly trash. Of course if you are a classic lucky player like my opponents, its a reliable and convenient food provider. But if you are me, its a rock that does nothing. If you try to use it and it fail (1/6 chance on a new roll, more when your opponents killed the birdfeeder), you lost the game. Gg see you next. This is the only type of card that can fail doing what they are supposed to do. Other random stuff are typically hunting birds, but they give uncapped points so its acceptable to fail. Flycatcher will fail doing is only purpose, you cant rely on it. And once again, its now competing with American Redstart. Im curious to see the winrate of an American Redstart on starting hand. Silly card i dont have in my physical version of the game.
FrankJones
Posts: 2928
Joined: 30 June 2024, 00:24

Re: Why do we keep trash cards

Post by FrankJones »

Madlaine wrote: ↑04 January 2026, 11:18 Great Crested Flycatcher is uterly trash. Of course if you are a classic lucky player like my opponents, its a reliable and convenient food provider. But if you are me, its a rock that does nothing. If you try to use it and it fail (1/6 chance on a new roll, more when your opponents killed the birdfeeder), you lost the game. Gg see you next. This is the only type of card that can fail doing what they are supposed to do. Other random stuff are typically hunting birds, but they give uncapped points so its acceptable to fail. Flycatcher will fail doing is only purpose, you cant rely on it. And once again, its now competing with American Redstart. Im curious to see the winrate of an American Redstart on starting hand. Silly card i dont have in my physical version of the game.
Hi,

I'm nearly 500 Elo at This game. I have won with the Great Crested Flycatcher as my first forest bird twice in my previous 15-20 games.

Among other things you said:

1) 1/6 is wrong for the probability of a failure on a new roll.
2) There are other birds that can also fail to get food. Are you of the opinion that this is the only bird that requires a specific food from the feeder?
3) The reason some players are rated 500 (or 600 or 700 or 800) and other players are not, is not because of luck. In the short run there is some variance. In the long run, the better players will achieve expert or master status.

4) Yes, the American Redstart is a very strong card. There are other strong cards. Most starting hands do not have a bird that strong. I mean, 1 time out of 36 your opponent has the Redstart. And one time out of 36, you will. On average.
MartoTom
Posts: 31
Joined: 19 March 2020, 10:38

Re: Why do we keep trash cards

Post by MartoTom »

FrankJones wrote: ↑31 December 2025, 15:47
MartoTom wrote: ↑31 December 2025, 09:04
It hasn't been your experience that re-rolling 5 dice and getting 0 nectar can be a game-losing moment, or that taking an action to lay 2 eggs, instead of just getting them for free outside your turn is a wasted turn? I issued a challenge to someone who swears that Oceania is the best thing since sliced bread. The challenge is simple: win a game without a bird that allows you to lay eggs passively. Just re-draw the card when you get one, or whatever. It happened once in more than 10 games. That to me speaks volumes about the way Oceania works.
Correct, this has not been my experience.

1) Yes, rerolling and not getting the desired food can be a problem. But at least with Nectar involved, I'm less likely to have a bird feeder situation where I simply cannot even take the gain food action at all because it would be a total waste given that the feeder has rat-cherry-fish and I need worm and grain. With 6 food types, and 3 of the 6 dice having a slash, I find disaster rolls to be less common.

2) I do not, and never have, understood this supposed issue with the weakened grassland habitat in Oceania. The same problem occurs without the Oceania board - In fact, during a recent run of frustrating games (here on BGA without Oceania), I was constantly egg-poor and had to take pathetically weak egg-laying actions just to be able to play more birds. With Oceania (which by default I assume to include EE as well), I find it less necessary to rely on my grassland because there are more options for doing things in different ways.
Thanks for proving my point that NOT LAYING eggs is one of the best things you can do in Oceania, as long as you find another option for it (since you need them at some point). Not sure what you understood when I shared my view, but it is the exact same thing you affirmed.
Post Reply

Return to “Wingspan”