Red Thumb system is obsolete

Suggestions & ideas / Suggestions & idées
Post Reply
Anne_Abi
Posts: 2
Joined: 20 November 2026, 12:09

Red Thumb system is obsolete

Post by Anne_Abi »

when has the Red Thumbs system evolved last ?
(i m talking about general cases, not insults)

>> some players put a RT to beginners just to avoid them

>> in some games such as Hanabi, RT are raining just because some players dont accept a move different than what they were expecting or casue you will refuse to concede a game and avoid not getting a perfect score

>> one game in a bad day, and the bad mood will make the player give or receive a RT

>> someone dont like or dont get your joke and you get a RT... text communication (via chat) can lead to various misinterpretations


The fact that 1 single Red Thumb will block the player forever is extremely radical
and the fact that it is irreversible by default (with no further action) is not acceptable

(a Master block a Beginner to avoid him, but the Beginner will learn and play better)

I am aware of current suggestion pages already opened about displaying the players you gave a Red Thumb before,
but in my opinion the issue is more profound

Red Thumbs should be like warnings and with a steps process
as long as there are no insults involved or such

for example, in a game you put a warning, it could appear on the table lobby BUT let the player seat anyway
(why would a player be denied a table if the host wants to play with him but only 1 other member gave a RT once ?)
then after several warnings, the player would be on another player block list

and they could have an expiration date, like 1 year

and they could not apply for other games if this not an issue due to the player behaviour


Blocking a player just with 1 Red Thumb, for a bad move, a bad day, makes no sense

please vote here https://boardgamearena.com/bug?id=257630
Anne_Abi
Posts: 2
Joined: 20 November 2026, 12:09

Re: Red Thumb system is obsolete

Post by Anne_Abi »

BGA actualk Red Thumb policy :
Giving a red thumb is a community-based player evaluation, and is 100% subjective. A player has the right to give you a red thumb if they do not enjoy playing with you. If you feel this is inappropriate, you may want to give this player a red thumb in return.
isn't it kind of childish ?
only response to a potentially unjustified or exagerated action is to do the same ?
User avatar
Jellby
Posts: 3839
Joined: 31 December 2013, 12:22

Re: Red Thumb system is obsolete

Post by Jellby »

Player A says they don't want to play with player B. The reasons are irrelevant.

What should BGA do? What should player B do?
Post Reply

Return to “Suggestions”