Board Game Afterwork: Work hard, play harder!

Board Game Arena Official announcements
User avatar
tchobello
Posts: 725
Joined: 18 March 2012, 13:19

Re: Board Game Afterwork: Work hard, play harder!

Post by tchobello »

miklomike wrote: ↑20 November 2026, 20:28 75% of the new games don't have any rules summary, which is on track with everything else you release. People don't bother to try games of you make it difficult to learn them.
What about simply clicking on the rules link or following the tutorial?

Rules summary and translations are community-made, often hastily put together, and can be quite poor, sometimes completely misrepresenting the original work.
User avatar
GTSchemer
Posts: 1282
Joined: 09 August 2013, 03:26

Re: Board Game Afterwork: Work hard, play harder!

Post by GTSchemer »

tchobello wrote: ↑21 November 2026, 11:12
miklomike wrote: ↑20 November 2026, 20:28 75% of the new games don't have any rules summary, which is on track with everything else you release. People don't bother to try games of you make it difficult to learn them.
What about simply clicking on the rules link or following the tutorial?

Rules summary and translations are community-made, often hastily put together, and can be quite poor, sometimes completely misrepresenting the original work.
This is not true of all developers. I made the rules summary by hand for each game I developed. I suspect some others may do the same.

It is a little strange a rules summary by the developer isn't a normal release step, which would avoid this issue.
User avatar
Tisaac
Posts: 2775
Joined: 26 August 2014, 21:28

Re: Board Game Afterwork: Work hard, play harder!

Post by Tisaac »

GTSchemer wrote: ↑21 November 2026, 13:42
tchobello wrote: ↑21 November 2026, 11:12
miklomike wrote: ↑20 November 2026, 20:28 75% of the new games don't have any rules summary, which is on track with everything else you release. People don't bother to try games of you make it difficult to learn them.
What about simply clicking on the rules link or following the tutorial?

Rules summary and translations are community-made, often hastily put together, and can be quite poor, sometimes completely misrepresenting the original work.
This is not true of all developers. I made the rules summary by hand for each game I developed. I suspect some others may do the same.

It is a little strange a rules summary by the developer isn't a normal release step, which would avoid this issue.
Strongly disagree with that last part, it's not a developper work at all. Now you might ask publisher to give one before the release, why not, but even that might not be always that positive because players will think Reading this is enough to play the game. It is NOT the case for almost all the games. There are tutorials and rulebook for a reason, a quick summary is just not the same thing.
User avatar
GTSchemer
Posts: 1282
Joined: 09 August 2013, 03:26

Re: Board Game Afterwork: Work hard, play harder!

Post by GTSchemer »

Tisaac wrote: ↑21 November 2026, 14:35 Strongly disagree with that last part, it's not a developper work at all. Now you might ask publisher to give one before the release, why not, but even that might not be always that positive because players will think Reading this is enough to play the game. It is NOT the case for almost all the games. There are tutorials and rulebook for a reason, a quick summary is just not the same thing.
Of course you are allowed to disagree. In my experience, I've found one of the surest signs someone understands something thoroughly is if they can teach it to others.

Since developers have to understand game rules very well to make a game, it seemed a natural fit to me for such people to write a general summary that doesn't misrepresent the game.

It's also one of the single shortest parts of development, like 1 day without using AI even for complex games, so I didn't consider it a burden and the benefits for the community are nice.
User avatar
Tisaac
Posts: 2775
Joined: 26 August 2014, 21:28

Re: Board Game Afterwork: Work hard, play harder!

Post by Tisaac »

[quote=GTSchemer post_id=273921 time=1795276601 user_id=81992]
[quote=Tisaac post_id=273915 time=1795268106 user_id=154830]
Strongly disagree with that last part, it's not a developper work at all. Now you might ask publisher to give one before the release, why not, but even that might not be always that positive because players will think Reading this is enough to play the game. It is NOT the case for almost all the games. There are tutorials and rulebook for a reason, a quick summary is just not the same thing.
[/quote]
Of course you are allowed to disagree. In my experience, I've found one of the surest signs someone understands something thoroughly is if they can teach it to others.

Since developers have to understand game rules very well to make a game, it seemed a natural fit to me for such people to write a general summary that doesn't misrepresent the game.

It's also one of the single shortest parts of development, like 1 day without using AI even for complex games, so I didn't consider it a burden and the benefits for the community are nice.
[/quote]
Explaining a game is vastly different from coding it, just as the same way as being an expert in maths does not make you a good teacher at all. From my experience in the academic domain, it's even usually the opposite because experts have hard time to remember what it's like to know nothing about something.
I am not saying it's not positive but just that it should be the publisher's job, in the same way that providing images for promoting the game is done by the publisher, not by dev. And also i am a bit dubious of players saying they cant play the game because this section isnt here. It's a nice thing to have but does not replace a rulebook or a tutorial.
User avatar
tchobello
Posts: 725
Joined: 18 March 2012, 13:19

Re: Board Game Afterwork: Work hard, play harder!

Post by tchobello »

GTSchemer wrote: ↑21 November 2026, 16:56 It's also one of the single shortest parts of development, like 1 day without using AI even for complex games, so I didn't consider it a burden and the benefits for the community are nice.
IRC, rules summaries aren't translated, whereas tutorials are.
Post Reply

Return to “Official announcements [en]”