Wood Duck > Big 4? A simulation-based tier list

Forum rules
Please DO NOT POST BUGS on this forum. Please report (and vote) bugs on : https://boardgamearena.com/bugs
horse_feed
Posts: 8
Joined: 03 November 2026, 22:33

Re: Wood Duck > Big 4? A simulation-based tier list

Post by horse_feed »

crocuspocus wrote: ↑19 November 2026, 05:49 "The computer plays a raven in about 1 game in 200 and almost never takes the egg trade when it does." -- You found the problem... it seems to me that the computer found one strategy (get food + play point bombs) and may be executing it reasonably competently. Perhaps other strategies (make a grassland engine) require too much planning for it to have figured out.
Or it's just truly bad to use the egg trade and the computer was just using the raven for other purposes.
crocuspocus wrote: ↑19 November 2026, 05:49 Also I would beat the computer 5/5 times in base game if given a broken bird to start (apparently you can give the computer one too since it won't know what to do with it).
Proof? :)
User avatar
RazorOz
Posts: 480
Joined: 25 June 2022, 13:58

Re: Wood Duck > Big 4? A simulation-based tier list

Post by RazorOz »

horse_feed wrote: ↑21 November 2026, 01:00 Or it's just truly bad to use the egg trade and the computer was just using the raven for other purposes.
What other purposes? The Ravens are clearly awful if you aren't using the egg trade. Like you've got to think here, what are the chances that pretty much everyone to ever play the game is wrong, and the computer knows better? Pretty much zero. It's why I say you've got to be careful blindly following AI analysis, I'm seeing it for a number of games where people are posting AI analysis that disagrees with the accepted norms like it's some new insight, when all it is in reality is the AI isn't properly trained to play those games yet.
horse_feed
Posts: 8
Joined: 03 November 2026, 22:33

Re: Wood Duck > Big 4? A simulation-based tier list

Post by horse_feed »

RazorOz wrote: ↑22 November 2026, 01:51
horse_feed wrote: ↑21 November 2026, 01:00 Or it's just truly bad to use the egg trade and the computer was just using the raven for other purposes.
What other purposes?
can you think of any?
crocuspocus
Posts: 5
Joined: 25 August 2025, 08:13

Re: Wood Duck > Big 4? A simulation-based tier list

Post by crocuspocus »

horse_feed wrote: ↑21 November 2026, 01:00 Proof? :)
Happy to prove it if it's feasible for me to play the AI :)
FrankJones
Posts: 2931
Joined: 30 June 2024, 00:24

Re: Wood Duck > Big 4? A simulation-based tier list

Post by FrankJones »

I'll be on myself with a "D tier" card (a raven) and 4 random cards against this AI.
Post Reply

Return to “Wingspan”