Direct Hit information leak

Forum rules
Please DO NOT POST BUGS on this forum. Please report (and vote) bugs on : https://boardgamearena.com/bugs
Post Reply
User avatar
B0Bftl
Posts: 2
Joined: 18 October 2026, 07:46

Direct Hit information leak

Post by B0Bftl »

Hello!

If you have Direct Hit in your hand, this info is easily leaked to your opponents during combat, but it's very critical info, and you generally do not want your opponent to know if you have it or not.

When you have a direct hit in your hand with active timer, if an opponent sustains damage, the turn goes back to you offering you the time window for playing direct hit.
If you as a player choose to sustain Damange, and no timer appears, you have a huge information gain, as you now know that your opponent does not have direct hit (or does not have it active, but that's not really feasible for this card in basically any combat).
At the moment, the information gain is unavoidable for the sustaining player, and does give a bad feeling on both sides.
Especially if you have a Dreadnought and your Flagship / Warsun, you can safely sustain with those, as soon as the dreadnought did not trigger the direct hit timer.

My Proposition for a fix:
At the start of combat, in the timeframe "Before combat", a user that has direct hit may select ships he wants to hit, if the opportunity arises. The targerts are in order, such that the card is played as desired when multiple valid targets are available, e.g.
1. Flagship
2. Dreadnought
A general "I do not want to play it this combat" is an option as well.
It may be canceled / adjusted anytime before usage, by going to the card in the UI during combat.
If a rule is set, no direct hit timer appears, but instead its either automatically played or withheld.

This way, a player can play all combats without leaking information about having Direct Hit or not.

Would be great to implement some way to get around this very critical info leak :)
RequestedSquirrel
Posts: 2
Joined: 11 February 2024, 19:22

Re: Direct Hit information leak

Post by RequestedSquirrel »

I also stumbled across this issue in a recent game, where my opponent did not get the timer on my first usage of sustain damage. The information, that he therefore did not have the card was extremly impactfull for me in that game, but I should not have had this information.

I support your idea with a more detailed timer configuration on the direct hit card. It does not need to happen in every start combat phase, it could also just be a global configuration on the card itself, but either way would work.
User avatar
GTSchemer
Posts: 1283
Joined: 09 August 2013, 03:26

Re: Direct Hit information leak

Post by GTSchemer »

Such a suggestion could be created in the Twilight Imperium suffering bug/suggestion tracking system so players can discuss and vote on it.
User avatar
B0Bftl
Posts: 2
Joined: 18 October 2026, 07:46

Re: Direct Hit information leak

Post by B0Bftl »

Good idea, created an entry.
If you're interested in a fix, please vote :)
https://boardgamearena.com/bug?id=257466
Jape2020
Posts: 8
Joined: 27 January 2021, 04:37

Re: Direct Hit information leak

Post by Jape2020 »

Noticed the same thing with "Sabotage." First time I played an action card, I had to wait for two other players to pass before I could proceed. While I didn't know for SURE it was sabotage it was an obvious deduction. Meanwhile, I had a Direct Hit in my hand I hoped to use against either one of these opponents, so I held off on a planned attack.

A round later, I deliberately burned two other action cards I didn't really care about that much but which, nonetheless, affected the two players. They both took the bait and played "Sabotage" to cancel them. The next time I played an action card, there was no timer — so I knew I could launch my attack with the Direct Hit card. That some serious inside intel there!
User avatar
GTSchemer
Posts: 1283
Joined: 09 August 2013, 03:26

Re: Direct Hit information leak

Post by GTSchemer »

Jape2020 wrote: ↑22 November 2026, 16:45 Noticed the same thing with "Sabotage." First time I played an action card, I had to wait for two other players to pass before I could proceed. While I didn't know for SURE it was sabotage it was an obvious deduction. Meanwhile, I had a Direct Hit in my hand I hoped to use against either one of these opponents, so I held off on a planned attack.

A round later, I deliberately burned two other action cards I didn't really care about that much but which, nonetheless, affected the two players. They both took the bait and played "Sabotage" to cancel them. The next time I played an action card, there was no timer — so I knew I could launch my attack with the Direct Hit card. That some serious inside intel there!
If you are curious, there are a couple of technical discussions linked from the FAQ about why it works this way by default: https://boardgamearena.com/bug?id=144240

In particular, waking all players every time an action card is played might add weeks of play time to an async game. It's possible to bluff using a manual alert, and that may become even simpler in the future, but it is likely not all players want the extreme game length of all players needing to wake up with nothing to do but pass any time an action card is played.
Post Reply

Return to “Twilight Imperium: Fourth Edition”