Hi @volker78,
first of all, thanks a lot for this great implementation of a classic board game, one of my favorites.
I'm now on "reviewing" a game, so I'm not sure if this is the correct place to put the feedback?
Anyway:
- first impression, was very good
- very intuitive, we almost never doubted on how to proceed with our actions
Some remarks:
- a first remark we did have was the colors. They might have to be made a bit more distinctive (I'm colorblin, but even my friends had issues making distinctions). Also there seems to be a difference in the color of the name of the player and their actual color.
- probably you thought of giving the option of a short (6rounds) and a long game (9rounds)
- When playing with five, by the second half of the game, a lot of players caballeros are on the board. Might be a suggestion to add an overlay on each province displaying the total of Caballeros + also the number of each player.
Some minor suggestions:
- The mobile scoreboard could be made a bit clearer (so it stands out to the rest)
- Is it an option of adding an "undo action" when you have chosen a card, but not played it yet?
We also found some bugs (you might be able to replay our game to see so):
- at a certain moment I placed 5 caballeros (King's card) + I moved the King + I was able to add again 5 caballeros (which I did not do, because of the sake of the game, but there must be some logic wrong there)
- During our game scoring Valencia was wrong: 3rd place only got 1 point
Looking forward to playing it again soon and to see the progress!
Again many thanks!
first of all, thanks a lot for this great implementation of a classic board game, one of my favorites.
I'm now on "reviewing" a game, so I'm not sure if this is the correct place to put the feedback?
Anyway:
- first impression, was very good
- very intuitive, we almost never doubted on how to proceed with our actions
Some remarks:
- a first remark we did have was the colors. They might have to be made a bit more distinctive (I'm colorblin, but even my friends had issues making distinctions). Also there seems to be a difference in the color of the name of the player and their actual color.
- probably you thought of giving the option of a short (6rounds) and a long game (9rounds)
- When playing with five, by the second half of the game, a lot of players caballeros are on the board. Might be a suggestion to add an overlay on each province displaying the total of Caballeros + also the number of each player.
Some minor suggestions:
- The mobile scoreboard could be made a bit clearer (so it stands out to the rest)
- Is it an option of adding an "undo action" when you have chosen a card, but not played it yet?
We also found some bugs (you might be able to replay our game to see so):
- at a certain moment I placed 5 caballeros (King's card) + I moved the King + I was able to add again 5 caballeros (which I did not do, because of the sake of the game, but there must be some logic wrong there)
- During our game scoring Valencia was wrong: 3rd place only got 1 point
Looking forward to playing it again soon and to see the progress!
Again many thanks!
