Calza with 2 players and under bid should NOT be allowed

[Sandrokkio77]

I find there is a major issue on Calza in this adaptation on BGA which doesn't match the Asmodee rules.
As a matter of fact, in the official rules Calza can only be called in a different turn and NOT when it's your turn to bet. So the current player can only bet or say Dudo and NOT say Calza. This makes the game much more fun and risky, avoiding to give the current player all the 3 possible options (the previous bid is too high --> Dudo, the previous bid is too low --> New bidding, the previous bid is just right --> Calza.

Very importantly, Calza can't be called during Palifico rounds (too easy) and when only two players are left.

Moreover, a player CANNOT be Palifico twice in a game, but just once. If you recover a dice with Calza and lose it again, no double advantage for you.

Three points to fix here, and this is the reason why a lot of players on here decide not to use the Calza variant, which adds a lot of fun and push-your-luck character to the game.

[Mister Pétard]

Salut.
Tes remarques entre la différence des règles Asmodee du jeu de Perudo et celles de bga sont justes mais tes conclusions sont complètement erronées. Les adaptations que tu critiques, après seulement quelques parties, qui ont dû te perturber, sont vraiment une amélioration des règles qui enrichissement considérablement le jeu. La grande majorité, pour ne pas dire tous les joueurs chevronnés, préfèrent beaucoup jouer comme ça. Avec cette formule de calza et de palifico, la place laisser au hasard des jeux est réduite au profit de la recherche de la bonne manière de jouer pour gagner.

[Mister Pétard]

.Hi.
Your observations regarding the differences between Asmodee's rules for Perudo's game and those of bga are valid, but your conclusions are completely wrong. The adaptations you criticize, after only a few games (which must have confused you), are actually an improvement to the rules that significantly enriches the game. The vast majority, if not all, experienced players much prefer playing this way. With this calza and palifico formula, the role of chance in the games is reduced in favor of finding the right way to play to win.