Is this game still going away?

Forum rules
Please DO NOT POST BUGS on this forum. Please report (and vote) bugs on : https://boardgamearena.com/bugs
adamgm
Posts: 3
Joined: 19 April 2025, 13:46

Is this game still going away?

Post by adamgm »

I hadn't bothered learning this game with the previous announcement that it's existence here was going to be temporary. I'm not sure if I'm missing it, but I can't find that information in the description anymore.

Is the game staying?

Thanks.
User avatar
Jellby
Posts: 3544
Joined: 31 December 2013, 12:22

Re: Is this game still going away?

Post by Jellby »

An admin of the players group (https://boardgamearena.com/group?id=17689256), who's not the developer or a BGA admin (so they may be in the publisher's side) said that "It will remain available for at least 6 months" 5 months ago, and "It will remain available for at least 5 more months" 4 months ago. So I'd guess we'll have to wait ~1 month and see.
User avatar
PotionSeller
Posts: 12
Joined: 18 September 2016, 15:34

Re: Is this game still going away?

Post by PotionSeller »

Seems odd to for it to vanish altogether. There's still a few setup things that could be added (i.e. individually selecting scenarios), but I would've thought the game would just move to premium rather than disappear.
User avatar
OriginalTopCat
Posts: 3
Joined: 18 February 2022, 23:44

Re: Is this game still going away?

Post by OriginalTopCat »

Appears to be gone now :-(
User avatar
stjohnmccloskey
Posts: 1
Joined: 29 May 2015, 18:06

Re: Is this game still going away?

Post by stjohnmccloskey »

This is a bummer; the game was great!
User avatar
bag99
Posts: 1
Joined: 12 July 2021, 19:38

Re: Is this game still going away?

Post by bag99 »

What is the current status? Will the game return?
Aristotlemate
Posts: 2
Joined: 28 September 2025, 05:04

Re: Is this game still going away?

Post by Aristotlemate »

As much as I love this game, and rate it a 10/10, if they've removed it without warning, with no courtesy announcement, then I'm sad to say that they've lost a potential customer (the publisher - not BGA). Disappointed in the way that was handled - there one day, gone the next.
User avatar
Remkar
Posts: 444
Joined: 25 March 2021, 22:10

Re: Is this game still going away?

Post by Remkar »

Aristotlemate wrote: 03 December 2025, 06:08 As much as I love this game, and rate it a 10/10, if they've removed it without warning, with no courtesy announcement, then I'm sad to say that they've lost a potential customer (the publisher - not BGA). Disappointed in the way that was handled - there one day, gone the next.
I mean, this was always the communicated plan.

Posted 7 months ago:
"This Board Game Arena version of The Lord of the Rings™: Fate of the Fellowship is available for a limited time and features 10 playable characters and the 4 objective cards suggested for players' first game.

This game will be available for a 'limited time'.
/Gamehelpfateoffellowship
7 months ago
It will remain available for at least 6 months."

And then it was posted to the game group last week that it was being removed.

Nothing unexpected. I guess they could have given a 10 day count down or something, but if they said it would be available for 6 or so months and they took it down after about 7 months, it seems like everyone that wanted to try it online would have had a reasonable chance.

Personally, I love that I was able to test it out the first month or so, loved it, and bought a physical copy the day it was released. I would be thrilled if more games did this try before you buy model.
User avatar
Vihtori Jäähonen
Posts: 8
Joined: 29 March 2024, 11:15

Re: Is this game still going away?

Post by Vihtori Jäähonen »

Remkar wrote: 03 December 2025, 14:24
Aristotlemate wrote: 03 December 2025, 06:08 As much as I love this game, and rate it a 10/10, if they've removed it without warning, with no courtesy announcement, then I'm sad to say that they've lost a potential customer (the publisher - not BGA). Disappointed in the way that was handled - there one day, gone the next.
I mean, this was always the communicated plan.

Posted 7 months ago:
"This Board Game Arena version of The Lord of the Rings™: Fate of the Fellowship is available for a limited time and features 10 playable characters and the 4 objective cards suggested for players' first game.

This game will be available for a 'limited time'.
/Gamehelpfateoffellowship
7 months ago
It will remain available for at least 6 months."

And then it was posted to the game group last week that it was being removed.

Nothing unexpected. I guess they could have given a 10 day count down or something, but if they said it would be available for 6 or so months and they took it down after about 7 months, it seems like everyone that wanted to try it online would have had a reasonable chance.

Personally, I love that I was able to test it out the first month or so, loved it, and bought a physical copy the day it was released. I would be thrilled if more games did this try before you buy model.
+1
Aristotlemate
Posts: 2
Joined: 28 September 2025, 05:04

Re: Is this game still going away?

Post by Aristotlemate »

I was perhaps unduly harsh, and I apologise for that. But it did "rob" us of the chance to play "one last hurrah". Living somewhere where the game isn't available except at an exorbitant price, I still maintain that a 7 or 10 day courtesy warning would have been the best way to handle it. I hope that feedback can be taken on board. Because as nice as it was to be able to keep playing it after the 6 month mark, every day after that left us in a bit of a limbo, never knowing which play would be our last.
Post Reply

Return to “The Fate of the Fellowship”