Search found 264 matches

by Jontia
28 October 2026, 09:33
Forum: Catan
Topic: dice algorithm is clearly flawed
Replies: 4
Views: 69

Re: dice algorithm is clearly flawed

Sinnerman88 wrote: ↑28 October 2026, 03:20 Please fix this problem that everybody complains about.
A few people complain about it regularly. Everybody would be a lot more noisey considering that roughly 5,000 games a day of Catan are played on the site.
by Jontia
25 October 2026, 10:34
Forum: Luthier
Topic: Rules or bug?
Replies: 2
Views: 59

Re: Rules or bug?

Here are the rules for search from pg 14 of the rulebook. Rulebook Search: If an apprentice was assigned to the worker chip, players can pay a sum of 10 money and/or inspiration to look through the deck for a single card, looking only at the back of each card for either the instrument type, musical ...
by Jontia
13 October 2026, 17:55
Forum: Catan
Topic: Friendly robber ruining Catan
Replies: 36
Views: 3191

Re: Can we please change arena!

How is it that we have been stuck with the same set of arena rules for yet another session? There is no place in arena for "friendly robber". The problems with this setting have been documented throughout this thread and others. Worse is the continued play with only 3 as opposed to 4 play...
by Jontia
13 October 2026, 09:03
Forum: Five Tribes
Topic: Is 2 player fun?
Replies: 2
Views: 142

Re: Is 2 player fun?

2p is quite a different game. The ability to have two pawns/turns per round and ultimately to be able to sequence up to four turns in a row changes the play-style quite significantly. It's still the same game, but much more focus goes onto planning and chaining turns together rather than simply find...
by Jontia
13 October 2026, 08:57
Forum: Mountain Goats
Topic: Red thumbs in Arena: player comfort vs. room for manipulation?
Replies: 13
Views: 494

Re: Red thumbs in Arena: player comfort vs. room for manipulation?

There might be a solution: simply blocking the chat whenever you play against someone who has "blocked" you. That way, if there was any prior offense, communication is no longer possible. This might work for Mountain Goats, but dipping into other games forums you'll find people using red ...
by Jontia
10 October 2026, 09:35
Forum: Catan
Topic: Dice deck
Replies: 3
Views: 165

Re: Dice deck

Well, I've always been happy with the dice anyway, but looking at the way the Dice deck is set up it's spectacularly bizzare. - A stack with 36 cards is build. On these cards the results of 2 dices are written based on the expected statistical probabilities: 2=1; 3=2x; 4=3x; 5=4x; 6=5x; 7=6x; 8=5x; ...
by Jontia
02 October 2026, 08:03
Forum: Stone Age
Topic: Bloody variance, right ?!
Replies: 2
Views: 227

Re: Bloody variance, right ?!

lexistenz wrote: ↑01 October 2026, 20:01 is designed like this, players that pay premium have better rolls. Much better rolls. Pay to win.
No, it isn't.
by Jontia
26 September 2026, 12:26
Forum: Forest Shuffle
Topic: Add Undo Button?
Replies: 10
Views: 733

Re: Add Undo Button?

Game speed is already handled by the turn timer. If you want a quick game; set it low, want to agonise over your decisions; set it high. This is a different concern entirely. I don't think it is, because there's no requirement to use all your timer, and no endless bank to put it in. A game with a 3...
by Jontia
24 September 2026, 21:06
Forum: Backgammon
Topic: Ridiculous dice
Replies: 26
Views: 879

Re: Ridiculous dice

This is a pretty common feeling among players, hence all the threads and all the believers that only look at overall stats and not how individual games are affected. I'm not sure it is a common feeling. Because there have been 7.5 million games played on BGA and there are only 163 backgammon theads...
by Jontia
24 September 2026, 09:21
Forum: Backgammon
Topic: Ridiculous dice
Replies: 26
Views: 879

Re: Ridiculous dice

Every one of these threads ends up with people pointing out the stats on the dice rolls. What is left out of the frustration-discussion is the timeliness of the dice rolls in comparison to what was forced on the board. There are scenarios that will force you to leave a solo when you'd rather not. I...

Go to advanced search