Search found 238 matches

by Jontia
27 July 2026, 20:58
Forum: Mountain Goats
Topic: Proposal: Elo rating should be Arena-only, Play Mode-only, split into separate ratings, or apply under equal conditions
Replies: 8
Views: 69

Re: Proposal: Remove Elo tracking from Play Mode, keep it Arena-only

Cigma, you're right that ELO rating doesn't affect the arena results. But the thing is, all players participate in the ELO rating - both arena players and play mode players - but under different conditions: arena players can't choose their opponents, while play mode players can. That's why, in my o...
by Jontia
27 July 2026, 13:02
Forum: Mountain Goats
Topic: Proposal: Elo rating should be Arena-only, Play Mode-only, split into separate ratings, or apply under equal conditions
Replies: 8
Views: 69

Re: Proposal: Remove Elo tracking from Play Mode, keep it Arena-only

The ELO system is currently used to gate-keep access to the Arena, so you'd need to replace that system. You'd also need some system to let people who dislike the current Arena settings track their progress. While ELO and indeed Arena ratings are not any kind of perfect ranking system, and getting o...
by Jontia
23 July 2026, 15:22
Forum: Catan
Topic: Friendly robber ruining Catan
Replies: 31
Views: 1575

Re: Friendly robber ruining Catan

Who is it that makes the decisions as to what rules form part of the arena games? I feel like some kind of campaign is needed to protest the inclusion of Friendly Robber. Can't see it so far in this thread, but this comes up pretty regularly. Here's the relevant FAQ link; Gurus In short, the 100 pe...
by Jontia
16 July 2026, 00:27
Forum: Ticket to Ride
Topic: Why is arena 2 player in TTR?
Replies: 7
Views: 174

Re: Why is arena 2 player in TTR?

It's partly because it's faster. The arena format is selected by gurus. Gurus are the 100 people who have played the most games each month. You can play more games, if the games finish faster. Two player games finish faster. So people who like and play two-player games, finish more games, get to be ...
by Jontia
15 July 2026, 23:45
Forum: Catan
Topic: Friendly robber ruining Catan
Replies: 31
Views: 1575

Re: Friendly robber ruining Catan

And here we go for an other arena season with friendly robber activated... That's it, I won't play anymore You can always play outside the Arena, in normal ELO games with the setting you want. That's what I do because I recognise that the setting that I like, that are competitive will not get picke...
by Jontia
15 July 2026, 16:29
Forum: Forest Shuffle
Topic: Deer and Pro Account
Replies: 22
Views: 489

Re: Deer and Pro Account

The thing that I like about this "Game is rigged" argument is that programming a game this way would be complex, therefore more expensive, to design. It would be liable to require more maintenance (tinkering with), therefore more expensive to run, and for what purpose? Any business that i...
by Jontia
13 July 2026, 13:21
Forum: Catan
Topic: How to change default settings?
Replies: 4
Views: 299

Re: How to change default settings?

Someone has pink color in catan. But the 4 default colors aren't pink. So, I've tried myself to put a color which isn't default and I can't choose that color. How come is that? I have the color pink in Catan. You can set your color preferences in Profile -->About-->Update your information-->Appeara...
by Jontia
10 July 2026, 20:28
Forum: Catan
Topic: Traded then immediately use a Knight to steal it back
Replies: 8
Views: 269

Re: Traded then immediately use a Knight to steal it back

My issue was more with the sequence and intent. They initiated a trade, gave me ore, and then immediately played a Knight targeting me, which made it feel like the trade was being used as setup for the steal rather than a normal good-faith exchange. So I’m not saying it was illegal or technically c...
by Jontia
29 June 2026, 23:19
Forum: Catan
Topic: Change dice rolling algorithm
Replies: 13
Views: 420

Re: Change dice rolling algorithm

Gotta say White plays a blinder in this game. Considering the other two players robbed from white exclusively for the entire game.
by Jontia
28 June 2026, 10:47
Forum: Catan
Topic: New Variant : Dice Deck
Replies: 22
Views: 1275

Re: New Variant : Dice Deck

Note: This procedure is different than the one explained in the Traders & Barbarians expansion, because in online play it may be possible that a player can has a higher chance to predict the next number, if the dice results are written down secretly. This would not be so easy in a game at a tab...

Go to advanced search