Search found 9 matches

by Bruce Idaho
17 August 2026, 18:21
Forum: Catan
Topic: Scoring Arena Points
Replies: 2
Views: 146

Re: Scoring Arena Points

Of course how close the game is should obviously matter. Me losing 10-9 to a player who is ranked 70+ points higher should not result in me losing any points in this game. Me losing 10-4 (but still coming in 2nd) to a player ranked 70+ points lower should result in me losing some points. The rules h...
by Bruce Idaho
11 August 2026, 01:59
Forum: Catan
Topic: Scoring Arena Points
Replies: 2
Views: 146

Scoring Arena Points

I hate the random scoring points aspect of Catan Arena games. I just lost 10-9 to a player who was ranked 70 points higher than me, and I received zero points. That makes absolutely no sense.
by Bruce Idaho
06 August 2026, 21:12
Forum: Discussions
Topic: Points for winning a game.
Replies: 16
Views: 567

Points for winning a game.

I just won an Arena game. I am rated in the low 100's. A 201 rated player came in second. And I won one stupid point for winning? Seriously moderators that makes no sense. Winning an Arena game should give the winner at least 3-4 points. I love the game, but some of the BGA rules make the game a lot...
by Bruce Idaho
31 July 2026, 14:49
Forum: Suggestions
Topic: Scoring points for 2nd place
Replies: 2
Views: 146

Scoring points for 2nd place

I just lost 10-9 to a player who is rated 375 (I am rated 127), and I received one point. That is idiotic.
by Bruce Idaho
28 February 2026, 05:27
Forum: Catan
Topic: change the dice generator.
Replies: 106
Views: 4401

Re: change the dice generator.

I agree. The numbers 4, 5, 9 and 10 always seem to come up more often than 6 & 8 do.
by Bruce Idaho
20 February 2026, 17:41
Forum: Catan
Topic: change the dice generator.
Replies: 106
Views: 4401

Re: change the dice generator.

I agree. The numbers 4, 5, 9 and 10 come up way more often than 6 or 8. Also, immediately once a player has 8 or more resource cards the number 7 will roll. It ruins the flow of the game, it is very, very frustrating and it slows the game down dramatically. It would be such a simple fix to change th...
by Bruce Idaho
17 February 2026, 18:24
Forum: Catan
Topic: Game points players receive are so illogical
Replies: 3
Views: 151

Game points players receive are so illogical

I just played a game. I was ranked approx.106, and the other two players were ranked approx. 201 and 150. I came in tied for 2nd and lost 6 points. I lost to a player who was ranked twice as high as me. In this scenario, it would make way more sense if I had won 10 points instead of losing 6 points....
by Bruce Idaho
06 February 2026, 16:19
Forum: Catan
Topic: The rolling 7's rule when players have 8 or more cards
Replies: 11
Views: 646

The rolling 7's rule when players have 8 or more cards

The rule that when a 7 is rolled and players have 8 or more resource cards is so stupid because 7's are rolled way more frequently than they should which slows down the game so much and literally it takes away much of the fun of the game. The last game that I played, a seven was rolled for times whe...
by Bruce Idaho
01 February 2026, 02:00
Forum: Catan
Topic: When players have 8 or more resource cards....
Replies: 6
Views: 318

When players have 8 or more resource cards....

It is incredibly dumb how many times a 7 is rolled as soon as a player has 8 or more resource cards. It happened to me 3 times in the last game that I played. There should be a maximum number of times that a 7 is rolled when one or more players have 8 or more resource cards. A maximum of one time pe...

Go to advanced search