Does anyone else feel there are way more Euro games than Ameritrash games on BGA? Does BGA have a bias for Euro games?

Discussions about BGA (all languages)
Forum rules
Warning: challenging a moderation in Forum = 10 days ban
More info & details about how to challenge a moderation: viewtopic.php?p=119756
Post Reply
User avatar
Starwarrior1128
Posts: 183
Joined: 07 February 2023, 05:22

Does anyone else feel there are way more Euro games than Ameritrash games on BGA? Does BGA have a bias for Euro games?

Post by Starwarrior1128 »

And/or a bias against Ameritrash games? As a big Ameritrash player, I get so disappointed when the latest BGA game release is another Euro game. There's just so few Ameritrash games on BGA (for example like Bang! the wild west card game). I get the whole licensing issue, but I would expect both Euro and Ameritrash game companies would want to feature their games on BGA is about equal amounts to spread the word about their games among players, but it feels like BGA is overwhelmingly Euro. I've even emailed some Ameritrash game companies about showcasing their games on BGA, but I'm sure an official BGA representative contact request would get a more serious response. I really like the game adaptions on here, because they feel like were made be played online, like where you can legally move being highlighted on the board or instructions popping up at the top of the screen, while other board game sites don't do that.
User avatar
Nastaa
Posts: 193
Joined: 13 April 2020, 14:07

Re: Does anyone else feel there are way more Euro games than Ameritrash games on BGA? Does BGA have a bias for Euro game

Post by Nastaa »

From the F.A.Q.
What are the available games?
Board Game Arena offers a wide selection of board and card games, with a strong focus on modern ('European style') board games.
So to me the intention to favor euro games is clear and it's coherent that the games released are more often of that style.
RobertBr
Posts: 667
Joined: 08 July 2016, 15:57

Re: Does anyone else feel there are way more Euro games than Ameritrash games on BGA? Does BGA have a bias for Euro game

Post by RobertBr »

Starwarrior1128 wrote: 25 April 2023, 04:32 There's just so few Ameritrash games on BGA (for example like Bang! the wild west card game). I get the whole licensing issue, but I would expect both Euro and Ameritrash game companies would want to feature their games on BGA ...
Since you do not understand what those words mean the answer is no. Bang! is a parlor game. The games are not decided by BGA but by the work of individual developers, and that is going to respond to both popularity and relative difficulty in coding.
User avatar
Blacktango
Posts: 537
Joined: 18 April 2015, 12:15

Re: Does anyone else feel there are way more Euro games than Ameritrash games on BGA? Does BGA have a bias for Euro game

Post by Blacktango »

I agree with what was said before.

I would add that BGA was developed by a French team.
I guess BGA is well known by European (especially French) editors, who can decide to pay a developer to code their games for BGA.
I suppose Ameritrash games are more likely to be made by American editors, who may be less interested in BGA.
User avatar
cigma
Posts: 1459
Joined: 15 December 2020, 00:30

Re: Does anyone else feel there are way more Euro games than Ameritrash games on BGA? Does BGA have a bias for Euro game

Post by cigma »

I agree that there are more Eurogames than Ameritrash on BGA, but I'd say most games do not belong to either. There are so many more: Push your luck, deduction, abstract, cooperative, tile placement, set collecting, trick taking, party games... Note that not every game produced in the US is "Ameritrasch" and not every game produced in Europe is an "Eurogame". There are even "Eurogames" developped in the US (e. g. Tapestry)!
Starwarrior1128 wrote: 25 April 2023, 04:32 There's just so few Ameritrash games on BGA (for example like Bang! the wild west card game).
Maybe you would like to have a closer look at some of these (beyond Bang):
King of Tokio
Dungeon Twister
Super Fantasy Brawl
Blood Rage
None Shall Pass
Clash of Decks
Dungeon Roll
Colt Express
Arctic Scavenger
Gangsta
Boss Quest
The Battle for Hill 218
Dice Summoners
Talon
Good Cop Bad Cop
Krosmaster Blast
Castles of Caleira
Outlaws: Last Man Standing
Exploration Warzone
Krossmaster Arena
#zan_zendegi_azadi / #woman_life_freedom
#StandWithUkraine
Language is a source of misunderstanding. (Antoine de Saint-Exupery: The Little Prince) But it is also the source of understanding - it all depends on how you use it. :-)
User avatar
Jellby
Posts: 3575
Joined: 31 December 2013, 12:22

Re: Does anyone else feel there are way more Euro games than Ameritrash games on BGA? Does BGA have a bias for Euro game

Post by Jellby »

Also, games based on mechanics and/or luck are more amenable to online playing than games based on physical interaction (speed, face-to-face communication, etc.).
User avatar
Starwarrior1128
Posts: 183
Joined: 07 February 2023, 05:22

Re: Does anyone else feel there are way more Euro games than Ameritrash games on BGA? Does BGA have a bias for Euro game

Post by Starwarrior1128 »

Jellby wrote: 25 April 2023, 17:34 Also, games based on mechanics and/or luck are more amenable to online playing than games based on physical interaction (speed, face-to-face communication, etc.).
I don't know about that. Bang and Martian Dice plays pretty well on BGA and they has a lot of luck. I also feel that games that involve more face to face interaction (like for example Pandemic) plays pretty well online on BGA. With Pandemic, in my experience text chatting or voice chatting is enough to get through the game. And some Ameritrash games already uses apps to help with gameplay like where to place tiles and move monsters (like with Mansion of Madness), so it would be even easier to adapt them to fully be online/digital. For all we know, BGA might sitting on the licenses of several good Ameritrash games (like Arkham Horror or Red Dragon Inn), but they would rather pay money to develop more Euro games. BGG had already a poll of what games people want to see on BGA and Arkham Horror was among the top 5.
User avatar
Tisaac
Posts: 2736
Joined: 26 August 2014, 21:28

Re: Does anyone else feel there are way more Euro games than Ameritrash games on BGA? Does BGA have a bias for Euro game

Post by Tisaac »

Starwarrior1128 wrote: 26 April 2023, 07:26
Jellby wrote: 25 April 2023, 17:34 Also, games based on mechanics and/or luck are more amenable to online playing than games based on physical interaction (speed, face-to-face communication, etc.).
I don't know about that. Bang and Martian Dice plays pretty well on BGA and they has a lot of luck. I also feel that games that involve more face to face interaction (like for example Pandemic) plays pretty well online on BGA. With Pandemic, in my experience text chatting or voice chatting is enough to get through the game. And some Ameritrash games already uses apps to help with gameplay like where to place tiles and move monsters (like with Mansion of Madness), so it would be even easier to adapt them to fully be online/digital. For all we know, BGA might sitting on the licenses of several good Ameritrash games (like Arkham Horror or Red Dragon Inn), but they would rather pay money to develop more Euro games. BGG had already a poll of what games people want to see on BGA and Arkham Horror was among the top 5.
No they dont. They will pay for any hit, regardless of the type.
Last edited by Tisaac on 26 April 2023, 11:39, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
RicardoRix
Posts: 2542
Joined: 29 April 2012, 23:43

Re: Does anyone else feel there are way more Euro games than Ameritrash games on BGA? Does BGA have a bias for Euro game

Post by RicardoRix »

Probably a lack of understanding in how most games get developed onto BGA.

There are a lot of open licenses for all kinds of games to be developed. A developer sees the game they wish to develop and gets started.

If you would like to redress the perceived imbalance. Then just jump over to BGA Studio and start developing.
https://studio.boardgamearena.com/licensing

Or approach the game designers/publishers you want to see on here and ask them to give a license to BGA.

In most instances, BGA are just middlemen, there is no choice or decision to be made on the type of game. Only if it will work on-line and fits as a board-game adaption.

Is dobble a Euro game or Ameritrash game?... who cares... it's here if you want to play it. And there are 500 others if you don't like that one.
User avatar
ufm
Posts: 2039
Joined: 06 January 2017, 08:38

Re: Does anyone else feel there are way more Euro games than Ameritrash games on BGA? Does BGA have a bias for Euro game

Post by ufm »

Starwarrior1128 wrote: 26 April 2023, 07:26 For all we know, BGA might sitting on the licenses of several good Ameritrash games (like Arkham Horror or Red Dragon Inn), but they would rather pay money to develop more Euro games. BGG had already a poll of what games people want to see on BGA and Arkham Horror was among the top 5.
A bad conspiracy theory. In fact no developer reads such polls while choosing games to develop because it doesn't matter at all...
RicardoRix wrote: 26 April 2023, 09:44 In most instances, BGA are just middlemen, there is no choice or decision to be made on the type of game.
Post Reply

Return to “Discussions”