Norwegians is coming to town

Forum rules
Please DO NOT POST BUGS on this forum. Please report (and vote) bugs on : https://boardgamearena.com/bugs
RTRebuilder
Posts: 3
Joined: 19 April 2020, 18:17

Re: Norwegians is coming to town

Post by RTRebuilder »

It does 1 then the other, so the popup will ask you to pick a Whaling Boat (or Pass) THEN you can pick the Knarr as a second step (or pass)
That is what happened the first time I used that action in round 4. But in this round, it didn't do that. Could it be a bug?
User avatar
AQJ
Posts: 6
Joined: 02 September 2024, 19:10

Re: Norwegians is coming to town

Post by AQJ »

Looking at your replay it definetly looks like a bug.

Disclaimer this is just speculation of what might have caused this.
I think what might have happened is that there is a build in immigration limit that wasn't properly updated for Norwegians. Normally in round 6 you'd be limited to 6 immigrations (as there is no more room) but because Norwegians introduced the 'half' whale boat immigrations it's possible to do more than six, it wouldn't surprise if there is a check somewhere that blocks you from taking more immigrations than the current turn counter.
User avatar
lysol255
Posts: 3
Joined: 28 December 2023, 22:01

Re: Norwegians is coming to town

Post by lysol255 »

Not sure if this was a minor bug or just I didn't understand the occupation correctly. I had Oil Seller and used the 2 upgrade space thinking any space with upgrades would trigger it but it didn't seem to activate and convert the 2 green into 3 blue.

I'm guessing that's just my hopeful interpretation of the card and it only activates on one specific spot on the board in Norwegians? Just mentioning it in case it is an issue and to help improve the overall experience. Thanks again for putting in the effort overall!
User avatar
danielvictor
Posts: 413
Joined: 02 February 2011, 09:29

Re: Norwegians is coming to town

Post by danielvictor »

I couldn't see the Norwegians' expansion rules in the rules section.I was able to hunt around for it on the net,but maybe they could add a link ?
User avatar
KeithHendricks
Posts: 129
Joined: 13 August 2020, 03:48

Re: Norwegians is coming to town

Post by KeithHendricks »

lysol255 wrote: 01 January 2025, 18:44 Not sure if this was a minor bug or just I didn't understand the occupation correctly. I had Oil Seller and used the 2 upgrade space thinking any space with upgrades would trigger it but it didn't seem to activate and convert the 2 green into 3 blue.

I'm guessing that's just my hopeful interpretation of the card and it only activates on one specific spot on the board in Norwegians? Just mentioning it in case it is an issue and to help improve the overall experience. Thanks again for putting in the effort overall!
In the appendix, page 8:

123 C Oil Seller
Immediately after each time you use an action space with a “^1 Good” action, you can exchange 1 oil for 1 silverware (even if you have just received the oil from the action).

So this is only on the spaces with 1 upgrade showing, not 2, 3, or 4 upgrades.
User avatar
Malaria
Posts: 1
Joined: 19 April 2020, 16:43

Re: Norwegians is coming to town

Post by Malaria »

Thank you for bringing us the Norwegians! I am quite enjoying my game.

Noticed and posted one bug so far for the 5th column "whaling boat + explore" option when playing on my phone.
After buying the boat, I never got the option of selecting an exploration board even though several were available and I had a long boat.
User avatar
KeithHendricks
Posts: 129
Joined: 13 August 2020, 03:48

Re: Norwegians is coming to town

Post by KeithHendricks »

Malaria wrote: 06 January 2025, 17:01 Thank you for bringing us the Norwegians! I am quite enjoying my game.

Noticed and posted one bug so far for the 5th column "whaling boat + explore" option when playing on my phone.
After buying the boat, I never got the option of selecting an exploration board even though several were available and I had a long boat.
The only islands you can buy there are the islands you can take on the 1 Viking explore: Lofoten, Isle of Man, Isle of Skye, Shetland, Faroe, Orkney, and Limerick. If those were all gone, no options would have appeared.
User avatar
lysol255
Posts: 3
Joined: 28 December 2023, 22:01

Re: Norwegians is coming to town

Post by lysol255 »

KeithHendricks wrote: 01 January 2025, 20:12
lysol255 wrote: 01 January 2025, 18:44 Not sure if this was a minor bug or just I didn't understand the occupation correctly. I had Oil Seller and used the 2 upgrade space thinking any space with upgrades would trigger it but it didn't seem to activate and convert the 2 green into 3 blue.

I'm guessing that's just my hopeful interpretation of the card and it only activates on one specific spot on the board in Norwegians? Just mentioning it in case it is an issue and to help improve the overall experience. Thanks again for putting in the effort overall!
In the appendix, page 8:

123 C Oil Seller
Immediately after each time you use an action space with a “^1 Good” action, you can exchange 1 oil for 1 silverware (even if you have just received the oil from the action).

So this is only on the spaces with 1 upgrade showing, not 2, 3, or 4 upgrades.
Cool yeah that's what I figured. Should it trigger on the 5th column action with the 2 resources 1 upgrade then? Its been a while but I think that was the space I used and it didn't trigger.
User avatar
KeithHendricks
Posts: 129
Joined: 13 August 2020, 03:48

Re: Norwegians is coming to town

Post by KeithHendricks »

lysol255 wrote: 11 January 2025, 03:16
KeithHendricks wrote: 01 January 2025, 20:12
lysol255 wrote: 01 January 2025, 18:44 Not sure if this was a minor bug or just I didn't understand the occupation correctly. I had Oil Seller and used the 2 upgrade space thinking any space with upgrades would trigger it but it didn't seem to activate and convert the 2 green into 3 blue.

I'm guessing that's just my hopeful interpretation of the card and it only activates on one specific spot on the board in Norwegians? Just mentioning it in case it is an issue and to help improve the overall experience. Thanks again for putting in the effort overall!
In the appendix, page 8:

123 C Oil Seller
Immediately after each time you use an action space with a “^1 Good” action, you can exchange 1 oil for 1 silverware (even if you have just received the oil from the action).

So this is only on the spaces with 1 upgrade showing, not 2, 3, or 4 upgrades.
Cool yeah that's what I figured. Should it trigger on the 5th column action with the 2 resources 1 upgrade then? Its been a while but I think that was the space I used and it didn't trigger.
You had written that you used the 2 upgrade action. It should work on the 5th column upgrade action as it follows the explicit text of the appendix (i.e. use an action with 1 upgrade). In addition, the Norwegians errata for the card (page 4) says that you can also use Oil Seller on the 3 resources + 2 weapon card action in the second column (likely as that is the action that replaces one of the 1x upgrade actions from the base game action board).
lazerlike42
Posts: 5
Joined: 24 January 2022, 04:53

Re: Norwegians is coming to town

Post by lazerlike42 »

KeithHendricks wrote: 11 January 2025, 03:27
lysol255 wrote: 11 January 2025, 03:16
KeithHendricks wrote: 01 January 2025, 20:12
In the appendix, page 8:

123 C Oil Seller
Immediately after each time you use an action space with a “^1 Good” action, you can exchange 1 oil for 1 silverware (even if you have just received the oil from the action).

So this is only on the spaces with 1 upgrade showing, not 2, 3, or 4 upgrades.
Cool yeah that's what I figured. Should it trigger on the 5th column action with the 2 resources 1 upgrade then? Its been a while but I think that was the space I used and it didn't trigger.
You had written that you used the 2 upgrade action. It should work on the 5th column upgrade action as it follows the explicit text of the appendix (i.e. use an action with 1 upgrade). In addition, the Norwegians errata for the card (page 4) says that you can also use Oil Seller on the 3 resources + 2 weapon card action in the second column (likely as that is the action that replaces one of the 1x upgrade actions from the base game action board).
I just had a few minutes ago a case where this card did FAIL to work correctly with the 5th column action.
Post Reply

Return to “A Feast for Odin”