Checked this thread for the first time in a while and thought I may as well chip in.
I believe that Guest Room was banned without ever being given a real fair shake. Sure, the card is powerful, but it was banned before any stats came out for the card itself and it stacks up with cards like Lover (that are not banned). In my opinion, this card should be unbanned.
Additionally, I am in favor of unbanning Informant. The card has a legitimate tradeoff where you're basically stuck having to spend any clay that you obtain during the same round that you took it in order to benefit from said card, but as Siveure was saying the Draft 10 community in this game appears to be strongly against this and I won't die on a hill for a card that I think is fine as the top-range of power you can come across in your drafts.
I am definitely against unbanning both Pulverizer Plow and Garden Designer. Garden Designer is a card that you can easily manufacture into giving you an obscene amount of points so long as you have any way of producing food, which is very easy to do in most revised games. Even at its worst you can basically just convert your animals into more points than they are normally worth so long as you have a cookery. Pulverizer plow is a card that completely destroys the clay economy; like Siveure was saying, sometimes this doesn't matter, however, if any player needs clay for their strategy to work their game is often ruined.
I believe that Guest Room was banned without ever being given a real fair shake. Sure, the card is powerful, but it was banned before any stats came out for the card itself and it stacks up with cards like Lover (that are not banned). In my opinion, this card should be unbanned.
Additionally, I am in favor of unbanning Informant. The card has a legitimate tradeoff where you're basically stuck having to spend any clay that you obtain during the same round that you took it in order to benefit from said card, but as Siveure was saying the Draft 10 community in this game appears to be strongly against this and I won't die on a hill for a card that I think is fine as the top-range of power you can come across in your drafts.
I am definitely against unbanning both Pulverizer Plow and Garden Designer. Garden Designer is a card that you can easily manufacture into giving you an obscene amount of points so long as you have any way of producing food, which is very easy to do in most revised games. Even at its worst you can basically just convert your animals into more points than they are normally worth so long as you have a cookery. Pulverizer plow is a card that completely destroys the clay economy; like Siveure was saying, sometimes this doesn't matter, however, if any player needs clay for their strategy to work their game is often ruined.
