Edge case

Forum rules
Please DO NOT POST BUGS on this forum. Please report (and vote) bugs on : https://boardgamearena.com/bugs
Post Reply
mynameis7
Posts: 3
Joined: 19 May 2025, 22:33

Edge case

Post by mynameis7 »

Although in real game this is not likely gonna happen, the 3-4 player main board can be filled by 10 workers such that no more workers could be placed. What would happen then?
User avatar
jordijansen
Posts: 247
Joined: 09 March 2023, 19:32

Re: Edge case

Post by jordijansen »

I don't believe it to be possible if you also consider mountain spaces, while those cost 1 resource to place on (and potentailly you don't have that, so there is an exception in the rules for this (and also implemented on BGA)):

Code: Select all

In very rare cases, when the only available space(s)
for your Crew member to be placed are Mountain hex(es), and
you do not possess any 1 resource to cover the cost, you may
place your Crew member on the Mountain(s) without paying
the cost.
mynameis7
Posts: 3
Joined: 19 May 2025, 22:33

Re: Edge case

Post by mynameis7 »

It is definitely possible. Of course I already considered mountain spaces.
I don't know how to upload a picture here. It is a bit hard to describe, but I'll try my best.

1-6 on left board:
1: 2 fruit 1 coral
2: 2 fruit (1 step on mountain) (between '3 fruit' and '2 fruit 1 mushroom')
3: 1 mushroom (1 step on mountain)
4-6: use rotational symmetry of 1-3

7,8 on mid board:
7: 1 mushroom
8: 1 flower (1 step on mountain))

9,10 on top-right:
9: 1 coral 1 flower
10: 1 fruit 1 mushroom (1 step on mountain) (from the x time-token then go down)
jordijansen wrote: 15 May 2026, 13:42 I don't believe it to be possible if you also consider mountain spaces, while those cost 1 resource to place on (and potentailly you don't have that, so there is an exception in the rules for this (and also implemented on BGA)):

Code: Select all

In very rare cases, when the only available space(s)
for your Crew member to be placed are Mountain hex(es), and
you do not possess any 1 resource to cover the cost, you may
place your Crew member on the Mountain(s) without paying
the cost.
User avatar
jordijansen
Posts: 247
Joined: 09 March 2023, 19:32

Re: Edge case

Post by jordijansen »

Yes, you're right. I've tried it out in a test game with 4 players: https://snipboard.io/Zstq9I.jpg

This isn't covered in the rules. BGA currently prevents further workers from being placed. This could result in a situation where players are unable to take any action if:
- They haven't placed all their workers, so they are not allowed to recharge.
- If they can't play any cards
- If they can't complete any achievements

While this is highly theoratical, and involves a lot of sub-optimal placements I think it wont happen too many times in "real" games.

Nevertheless, I've asked the publisher for clarification.
Post Reply

Return to “Wondrous Creatures”