Red Thumb system is obsolete

Suggestions & ideas / Suggestions & idées
Post Reply
Anne_Abi
Posts: 2
Joined: 20 November 2026, 12:09

Red Thumb system is obsolete

Post by Anne_Abi »

when has the Red Thumbs system evolved last ?
(i m talking about general cases, not insults)

>> some players put a RT to beginners just to avoid them

>> in some games such as Hanabi, RT are raining just because some players dont accept a move different than what they were expecting or casue you will refuse to concede a game and avoid not getting a perfect score

>> one game in a bad day, and the bad mood will make the player give or receive a RT

>> someone dont like or dont get your joke and you get a RT... text communication (via chat) can lead to various misinterpretations


The fact that 1 single Red Thumb will block the player forever is extremely radical
and the fact that it is irreversible by default (with no further action) is not acceptable

(a Master block a Beginner to avoid him, but the Beginner will learn and play better)

I am aware of current suggestion pages already opened about displaying the players you gave a Red Thumb before,
but in my opinion the issue is more profound

Red Thumbs should be like warnings and with a steps process
as long as there are no insults involved or such

for example, in a game you put a warning, it could appear on the table lobby BUT let the player seat anyway
(why would a player be denied a table if the host wants to play with him but only 1 other member gave a RT once ?)
then after several warnings, the player would be on another player block list

and they could have an expiration date, like 1 year

and they could not apply for other games if this not an issue due to the player behaviour


Blocking a player just with 1 Red Thumb, for a bad move, a bad day, makes no sense

please vote here https://boardgamearena.com/bug?id=257630
Anne_Abi
Posts: 2
Joined: 20 November 2026, 12:09

Re: Red Thumb system is obsolete

Post by Anne_Abi »

BGA actualk Red Thumb policy :
Giving a red thumb is a community-based player evaluation, and is 100% subjective. A player has the right to give you a red thumb if they do not enjoy playing with you. If you feel this is inappropriate, you may want to give this player a red thumb in return.
isn't it kind of childish ?
only response to a potentially unjustified or exagerated action is to do the same ?
User avatar
Jellby
Posts: 3840
Joined: 31 December 2013, 12:22

Re: Red Thumb system is obsolete

Post by Jellby »

Player A says they don't want to play with player B. The reasons are irrelevant.

What should BGA do? What should player B do?
User avatar
BarnardsStar
Posts: 710
Joined: 02 January 2021, 02:41

Re: Red Thumb system is obsolete

Post by BarnardsStar »

Anne_Abi wrote: ↑20 November 2026, 12:15 …
Your proposal is far too broad. A good bug report or feature suggestion should be highly specific and as limited in scope as possible, otherwise it becomes impossible to act upon. Your suggestion here is essentially “RTs are bad; here are some things you could do”. A good suggestion would be “I think you should do this specific thing to improve the system”.

I agree with the notion of having a proper management system for RTs. I agree that by default they should be of limited duration (but the management system should support changing that duration to other values including permanent).

The rest of this screed I cannot agree with. For example, the whole point is (as Jellby says) to prevent A and B from playing together. So yeah, if one of them joins the table first (no matter which), the other should be prevented from joining. That’s all there is to it and I do not support any aspect of this part changing. (If the host invited both of them specifically, the host should be warned they cannot play together; this may already be the case.)

If you break your suggestion up into specific components I will probably vote for some of them (but do a search to see they didn’t already exist), but I will not be voting for this suggestion.
User avatar
dizzymisslizzy17
Posts: 47
Joined: 18 January 2022, 23:13

Re: Red Thumb system is obsolete

Post by dizzymisslizzy17 »

IDK ...

If I give someone a RT, I don't want to play with them. End of story. I'd hate to be forced to play with them again just because a certain period of time had passed, or I maxed my number of RTs to give, or something like that.

RTs used to count against your karma - if you had too many RTs, your maximum karma score was lowered. I'm glad they removed that for the many reasons in OP's post.

But if you don't want to play with someone - for whatever reason - you shouldn't have to play with them. I've had people give me RTs without even playing a game with me ... not sure why, but their choice. I've had people give me RTs for reasons I can't figure out, or for reasons I very strongly disagree with. But at the end of the day, they don't want to play with me. I'd hate to force them to play with me again if they don't want to - that isn't fun for either of us.

I've also been known to remove RTs from people if I seem them playing and I feel like giving them a second chance. And then there are players that I won't because I remember why I gave them a RT. I don't want to be forced to play with them (especially in a co-op game like Hanabi, The Gang, Pandemic, The Crew, etc.)

It would be great if there was a page on BGA where you could see/review who you have given RTs and remove them if you want. That would be my only suggestion.
Post Reply

Return to “Suggestions”